Reducing Mud In Your Electronic Productions

Reducing Mud In Your Electronic Productions

Tutorial Details
  • Difficulty: Intermediate
  • Time: 30 minutes
  • Requirements: Logic Pro or other DAW

Electronic music tends to have a very pronounced separation of frequencies: thumping bass, crisp highs and warm mids are what most producers are going for in electronic music. One of the main topics that comes up when I’m chatting about audio production with fellow producers is taming the lower and middle frequencies in a mix.

Some producers will find themselves struggling to get the lower and middle frequencies sounding tight and clean the way they want. The term “mud” is usually used to describe a buildup of low and middle frequencies to an undesirable point. I want to share a tip that I’ve found makes a world of difference in helping get rid of muddy sounding frequencies, and that is using high pass filters.

For this tutorial I will be using samples from my latest production Space Cowboy, which you can listen to and download here:


High Pass Filtering Your Sounds

Now when I say use high pass filters, I mean literally use them on almost every thing. If it’s not a part of the production that is going to be dominating the lower and middle frequencies, it should be high pass filtered to some extent to push it into the upper frequency range.

The devil is really in the details when it comes to reducing the muddy sound of a production. Most if not all synths and samples you will use in your productions are going to have frequencies you don’t want in your mix.

When you hear an open high hat for example, the last thing you’re probably going to consider is what its frequency spectrum looks like and if there is any unwanted low frequencies. It’s a high hat after all, it’s going to be mostly high frequencies right?

But if you look at its frequency spectrum, you’ll be amazed at all the low frequency information that is present. This being a high hat you obviously want it for its higher frequency content, so there is no point in having the lower frequencies in your mix. Granted it is a single sample and the middle and low frequency content is minimal, but it doesn’t change the fact that it’s still there.

Even Percussion Samples Like High Hats Have Frequency Data That Will Contribute To A Muddy Mix
Even Percussion Samples Like High Hats Have Frequency Data That Will Contribute To A Muddy Mix

Most if not all synths and samples you will use in your productions are going to have frequencies you don’t want in your mix.

When you multiply this middle and low frequency content by however many samples you have for just the drum and percussion grooves of your track; this is where the unwanted frequencies start to creep in and muddy up in your mix.

In fact the only thing it is adding is rumble. And when that random rumble starts to interact with the other frequencies from the sounds that you add later, it starts to color the sound in a not so pleasant way.

This is even more true for synthesizers that are not using samples for their sound source. Given that more often than not some sort of signal processing is going to be applied to your synths, such as delay and echo; while they has a pleasing effect on the higher frequencies of synthesizers, the lower frequencies will quickly turn into nothing but noise. If you were too keep the lower frequencies of the synth, it would wreck havoc on the rest of the mix.

When Using Signal Processors Like Delay and Echo The Lower and Middle Frequencies Often Build Up Into Sonic
When Using Signal Processors Like Delay and Echo The Lower and Middle Frequencies Often Build Up Into Sonic “Mush”, Basically Noise.

Listen to the below samples of my track Space Cowboy to hear the difference using high pass filters makes. Be sure to listen to the sample of just the low noise, or “mud” that has been taken out of the track.

Example 01
High pass filters on all major parts

Example 02
All high pass filters bypassed

Example 03
An example of the middle and low frequency “mud” that has been removed


Mid/Side High Pass Filtering

Finally, if you have access to a equalizer or filter that has a mid/side function, you can also apply this concept by high pass filtering the sides, while leaving the middle frequency information in tact. Most systems play the lower frequencies in mono, so attenuating the middle and low frequencies on just the side channels will help clean up the mix and give you a tighter sounding middle and low end.

The slope that you use to high pass is up to your personal taste, but its generally accepted that a lower slope will give you a more analogue sounding filter as opposed to a sharp cutoff. Most analogue filters tend to have a gradual slope that gently tapers off the harmonics.

ALTTEXT
Using The High Pass Filter Technique With A Mid/Side EQ

Attenuating the middle and low frequencies on just the side channels will help clean up the mix and give you a tighter sounding middle and low end.

When EQing, always keep in mind that music is subjective. What sounds good to me may sound like crap to you. What sounds like “muddy” frequencies to me may be the exact TAMBER timbre you are going for. But it is still good to keep in mind the concepts.


Conclusion

I hope I’ve shown the reason for high pass filtering the individual parts of your mix. Keep in mind a few things: this is just one technique that you can use to help tame the frequency buildup commonly referred to as mud, and often you’ll end up using multiple techniques together when mixing. I know how discouraging it can be when you just can’t seem to get the sound you’re shooting for, so I really hope this helps you out.

  • Mike

    An important and handy tip this one, used with discretion.

    “this is just one technique that you can use to help tame the frequency build-up”
    If this was Tip#1 in a new series (focused on electronic music) I’d be very happy :)

    • http://www.robertanthonyperez.com Robert Anthony

      Hi Mike, glad you found the article helpful. Who knows, this may in fact evolve into a series on electronic music as EDM is my forte. Stay tuned!

  • Alyssa

    I’m sorry, but this is just an awful way to reduce mud. Sure, I high pass all my tracks, but I do that at 30hz to get rid of lingering sub frequencies. Most of the time when you’re dealing with lows and low mids you only need a cut of a few decibels, not a whole high pass filter. If you’re a newbie and you simply follow this tutorial, you’ll be scratching your head as to why this will work. Learn to EQ first.

    • http://soundcloud.com/robertanthonyp Robert Anthony

      Hi Alyssa, thanks for the feedback, no apologies needed!

      I think as a community of musicians and audio aficionados we can all agree that we will disagree. I realize that this would be helpful to some, old news to others, and still the completely wrong way to do it for others.

      Take it for what it is and if it’s helpful great, if not then by all means give your take on it. I’m the first to sit and listen to someone if they know something I don’t!

      I agree that a need to learn the principles of EQing is in order first. And during. And after. The point being that saying “learn to EQ” takes three words, but you can and people do make a career out of “learning to EQ” it’s such a massive topic.

    • http://nightshademusicgroup.com DJ SGZ

      Hi Alyssa,

      I say it all depends on how it sounds to your ears. It doesn’t matter if you cut 30Hz, 500Hz or below 200Hz… everyone has their own taste so if 30Hz sounds good to you then use that but I just prefer to keep everything clean and tidy so I can go as far as 200Hz or more just as long as it sounds good in the mix.

      And this tutorial is a guide line not a rule!

      Peace

  • http://soundcloud.com/saifb Unknown

    I think hp filters are awfull, they sometimes boost the high end. Its one of the reasons today’s electronic music sound so harsh. gentle curves with an eq are way better, plus you make sure there are no textures lost, and it doesn’t sound as thin. other than that, good tut. thanks.

    • http://soundcloud.com/robertanthonyp Robert Anthony

      Hi John (Doe lol), thanks for the input!

      I agree, straight High Pass filters aren’t the best tools to use. Maybe it was a mistake on my part to assume people would know the difference, but if you’ll notice I didn’t actually use a “High Pass” Plugin, but instead the default Logic Pro Channel EQ.

      Then using the Channel EQ I did just as you said with the slope of Band 1 (which is a high pass filter) set to 12 or 24 dB/Oct.

      I also mentioned in the Mid/Side section that a gentler slope tends to have more pleasing sound as it is not making the sounds paper thin like you said but keeping some of the lower frequencies (some being the key word).

  • http://nightshademusicgroup.com DJ SGZ

    Thnx for explaining the term “mud” in such a simple way, I find it hard to figure out where the muddiness is in my mixes. I always put a high pass filter in all instruments including the bass but whenever I ask the mastering engineer how did he make it sound so good.

    All of them will say, “I just removed some mud at…” but I’ll try the mid side technique though, haven’t tested that. Thnx for the Tip.

  • phylta

    Sounds like a cool tip, thank you

  • Aberration

    Two important remarks :
    When it comes to mixing, it’s BAD to do anything as a routine. Do not apply HPF on everything, apply only where needed (yes it takes time and training, but it worth it). That said, it might help for quick and dirty demos.

    “Most systems play the lower frequencies in mono” : this sentence makes no sense ! I understand what you mean, but it’s not the proper way to say this. High frequency have more directivity than lower one. Actually bellow ~85Hz it becomes almost impossible to tell where the sound comes from (that’s why you can place a sub pretty much anywhere in the room).

  • http://www.facebook.com/maikel.hoyos Maikel Hoyos

    Thanks for this vid…!!

    • Robert Anthony

      Glad you found it useful, Maikel!

  • http://twitter.com/BokoLuke Luke Moseley

    This is awesome dude, think I may go onto my templates and add in some simple HP & LP filters, so easy to forget this kind of stuff when mixing.

    • Robert Anthony

      Hi Luke, thanks for the feedback! A cool tip is that you can actually save over the default settings for the Channel EQ as well as the Linear Phase EQ. Just make an EQ with the settings you want, like a default high pass filter for example, then in the plug-in drop down select save and save it with the name “#default”.

      Then from now on when you call the plug-in up , it will have the settings you saved it with.